Insurance guides · Germany
Teilkasko or Vollkasko: At what vehicle age should you switch?
Why vehicle value, finance terms, excess and your ability to absorb a loss matter more than a fixed age threshold.
Fahrnex editorial team · Updated: 15 November 2026
The short answer
There is no universal vehicle age at which partial cover automatically becomes the better choice. Consider the car’s value, the extra premium and the loss you could afford yourself.
What is the difference in cover?
Teilkasko covers agreed risks such as theft or glass damage. Vollkasko additionally covers, in particular, accidental damage you cause to your own car and vandalism. Specific risks, exclusions and compensation limits depend on the policy.
How much does age matter?
An older car can still have a high replacement value. Conversely, an extra premium may be harder to justify for a low-value vehicle. For a leased or financed car, first check the contractual insurance requirements.
A calculation for your decision
Write down the current vehicle value and both annual premiums with comparable excesses. The difference shows the yearly extra cost of comprehensive cover. Then consider whether your savings could replace the car after a total loss you caused. This calculation does not replace checking the benefits.
Before changing cover
Obtain actual quotes for both options: a favourable comprehensive no-claims class can change the price gap. Ask which risks would no longer be covered after switching. A lower premium alone says little about the protection that remains.
Your checklist
- Estimate the vehicle’s value
- Check leasing or finance requirements
- Weigh the extra premium against the loss you can afford
Related guides
Sources and further reading
Sources accessed on 15 November 2026. Your policy and its applicable terms take precedence.